She is still angry that the arrest robbed her of the chance to defeat Greenberg. Asking for a friend.. Joel Greenberg A former Florida tax collector and close associate of Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) is facing a 45-page federal indictment alleging wire fraud, sex trafficking, and a litany of other offenses connected to the alleged abuse of his office and other crimes. . Initially released on bail, Greenberg, 35, was later returned to jail for violating his court-ordered curfew. Marshals Service re-arrested Greenberg and a federal judge revoked his bond and conditions of release.Greenberg is now being held in the Orange County Jail. One of the central figures in the Matt Gaetz Justice Department investigation is Joel Greenberg, the former tax collector for Florida's Seminole County who was indicted last summer . Multiple media outlets have reported that Greenberg has been talking with federal investigators since last year, and the U.S. Joel Greenberg is currently in lock up at the Orange County jail. . The divorce case remains open and unresolved. His family made their money from several clinics, called Greenberg Dental. Once the door was open, however, Greenbergs poorly-concealed trail of financial improprieties again, for allegedly stealing taxpayer funds to purchase items that he could have easily afforded to buy himself gave investigators ample additional evidentiary paths to follow. Greenberg was also sentenced to another 10 years of supervised release after his prison term. Defending himself in 2018 against the Islamophobia charge, Greenberg said that one of his brothers is. In the second half of 2017, the indictment charged that Greenberg did knowingly recruit, entice, obtain, maintain, patronize and solicit by any means the Minor Victim, with the knowledge that his victim was underage and that he was seeking a commercial sexual relationship. When the dispatcher asked if Dunn knew why, she responded: "Yeah, because he does bad things, like on federal house arrest. "I think if Joel Greenberg runs, with his ability to fundraise . An investigation revealed that Greenberg embezzled and diverted over $400,000 to buy cryptocurrency, to run a business that sold cryptocurrency mining machines, among others. When another election was held, school teacher Brian Beute ran against Greenberg but a scandal about sleeping with a student broke out. In 2020, Greenberg was arrested and charged with multiple federal offenses. He had help from a local Central Florida blogger. They quote at length from the 6 articles, and also speculate if this anomalous behavior played a part in his abrut departure to the Chicago Tribune in November 2002. Defending himself in 2018 against the Islamophobia charge, Greenberg said that one of his brothers is Black. The Gaetz investigation apparently grew out of an earlier investigation of Greenberg, according to the New York Times. Greenbergs immediate family are members of Northland Church, a moderate evangelical congregation in Longwood, an Orlando suburb, but Greenberg himself was not a regular attendee, according to the former pastor. Greenberg told Buzzfeed that the congressman is a champion of Israel and the Jewish people, adding, We may have to retroactively throw him a bar mitzvah.. I said, 'No problem,' and I'm like, 'I'm here.' He is reportedly cooperating with prosecutors in exchange for a lighter sentence a move which many observers are interpreting as highly dangerous for Gaetz and others in Greenbergs inner circle. I said, 'No problem,' and I'm like, 'I'm here.' I dont know anyone in the Jewish community who knows him, he said. [TRENDING: Florida Gov. [20][21] As part of the plea agreement, Greenberg must register as a sex offender. Prosecutors have said he is facing at least 12 years behind bars, but he has . When he found out his applications for the relief loans had been submitted, Greenberg allegedly texted his friend "How quickly can I blow this on p---y," according to "American Greed.". For a time, Greenberg appeared to be a rising political star, thanks in part to his relationship with Gaetz, who dubbed him a future congressman, and dirty trickster Roger Stone. When the radio show didnt work out, Greenberg went into politics and ran as a tax collector for the Seminole County. Philip Weiss is senior editor of Mondoweiss.net and founded the site in 2005-06. Gaetz has not been charged with any crimes and he has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing. June 15, 2020 Central Florida Post Facebook video: June 20, 2020 Central Florida Post Facebook video: Engels also repeatedly threatened Beute in the videos and in comments on the original Facebook posts that Beute shouldnt criticize Engels or his site ever again, Beute needs to drop out of the race, and vowing that Central Florida Post would publish the results of our work before the Republican primary. Please make a donation today, and consider becoming a monthly donor. Greenbergs fingerprints and DNA were found on the letters and investigators also traced some of the online attacks back to an IP address at Greenbergs residence. Greenberg denies all the charges. He is accused of creating a viciously false smear campaign against a primary opponent, Beute, who he most certainly would have beaten if he had just stayed quiet until after the primary. "One of my best friends is Muslim, and I have a Black brother," Greenberg told the Orlando Weekly. How Often Do Credit Card Frauds Get Caught? Four Jupiter police officers and a supervising sergeant responded to an apartment following the 911 call on Feb. 28. CNN Hosts Laugh Out Loud At DeSantis Disney Threat: I Mean Lets Play This Out, GOP Governor Says We Got Our Asses Kicked in 2022 Partly Because Fox Is An Echo Chamber, Tarlov Decries House Republicans Hearing on Crime in New York: Go to Alabama, Marjorie Taylor Greene Calls on FBI to Investigate Trump Ally Who Allegedly Asked Minors For Nude Photos, reportedly cooperating with prosecutors in exchange for a lighter sentence, highly dangerous for Gaetz and others in Greenbergs inner circle, talking with federal investigators since last year, re-arrested for violating the curfew rules of his pre-trial release, flashed his self-issued badge to pull over a woman for speeding, nearly $400,000 in questionable credit card charges, shortly after Gaetz sent Greenberg that exact amount, accused of soliciting the son of one of his employees, like the Tiger King got elected tax collector, may very well implicate Gaetz and other powerful Florida Republicans, a vocal opponent of the River Cross development project, abruptly resigned from his lobbying firm last week, still lost the primary by nearly 12 points, Letters were sent to the headmaster at Trinity Prep, Greenbergs fingerprints and DNA were found on the letters, ong been associated with self-proclaimed dirty trickster, at a federal hearing on February 23, 2019, numerous connections to the extremist group, a still-growing number of dominoes falling, When Greenberg was arrested at his home on June 23, 2020, reports of them traveling with young women, suddenly resigned his position in January of this year, Beshears and several young women traveling on Pirozzolos plane, the long list of his allies and associates, Scheller told reporters earlier this month, How the Justice Department came to investigate Rep. Matt Gaetz, Trump Calls On Fox News to FINALLY ADMIT False Claims of a Stolen 2020 Election in 2:30AM Social Media Post, Is He Even Literate? Fox News Host Slams Biased Judge in Dominion Case as Small Potatoes Running Clown Show, Jim Acosta Says New DeSantis PAC Ad Accusing Trump of Acting Like a Democrat Looks Like Something Democrats Would Run, YOURE A SCUMBAG! Hecklers Derail House Judiciary Hearing in NYC By Screaming at Adam Schiff, CNNs Elie Honig Suspects Fox News Got Cold Feet With Reported Late Push to Settle Dominion Lawsuit, Black Women Are Going to Die: MSNBCs Katie Phang and Guests Agree Being Pregnant In Florida Is Like a Death Sentence, Big Republican Donor And a Bunch of Friends Back Off DeSantis Over Culture War Politics: Very Big Problem, MSNBCs Ali Velshi Attacks Abortion Rulings And Bans As Christian Sharia Something That Muslims Never Did in America, DeSantis Ad Drops RIGHT Before Trumps NRA Speech Branding Him Coward on Guns: He Doesnt Deserve A Second Chance, This Has Not Ever Been a Pro-Life Movement: MSNBC Guest Goes on Absolute Tear Against Tim Scott. But in Greenbergs case, the Seminole County tax collector must provide federal investigators with testimony and evidence to help them with active investigations. Bottom line, there was an absolute deluge of news stories criticizing Greenberg for coloring far, far outside the lines regarding what his offices purposes and powers legally were, for allegedly spending taxpayer funds to benefit himself and to grantlucrative consulting contracts to his friends, and for just in general actinglike the Tiger King got elected tax collector, as a recent New York Timesheadline described him. HIS TRIAL IN FEDERAL COURT. Im sure Matt Gaetz is not feeling very comfortable, Joel Greenbergs attorney Fritz Scheller said last year, shortly before Greenberg accepted the governments plea offer. Gaetz contributed the maximum amount to Greenbergs campaign, and brought him along to a visit to the White House, according to the Times. He served as a tax collector in the county before his indictment in 2020. Even after he was arrested and charged, Greenberg continued his criminal activities. "I'm Jewish, which is probably one of the . He is not involved with the Jewish community in any way, making his association with us even more embarrassing.. [15] On February 28, 2021, Greenberg violated his bond conditions by traveling during his curfew hours, reportedly to look for his wife. The latest breaking updates, delivered straight to your email inbox. Joel Greenberg, a friend and business associate of US Representative Matt Gaetz, has been sentenced to 11 years in prison for sex trafficking a minor and stalking a political opponent.. Greenberg became a person of public interest after the Justice Department announced it was investigating minor sex trafficking allegations against Mr Gaetz.. Mr Gaetz has denied any wrongdoing and no charges . U.S. Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL) speaks during a news conference in front of the Capitol December 6, 2017 in Washington, DC. Even after Greenberg was arrested, resigned from office, and dropped his re-election bid, Beute still lost the primary by nearly 12 points to J.R. Kroll, who would go on to win the general election and is the current Seminole County Tax Collector. Last edited on 28 February 2023, at 15:18, Learn how and when to remove this template message, Production of a false identification document, "Seminole, Orange tax collectors make changes to prevent ID theft in the wake of Joel Greenberg's arrest", "Gaetz associate pleads guilty to sex trafficking charges", "Joel Greenberg, Friend and Associate of Matt Gaetz, Expected to Plead Guilty", "READ: Plea agreement from former Gaetz associate Joel Greenberg", "Joel Greenberg cooperating with feds since last year in Matt Gaetz sex trafficking probe: report", "Judge Approves Plea Deal, Sets Sentencing Date for Matt Gaetz Associate in Child Sex Trafficking Case", "Joel Greenberg Timeline: From rising Republican star to federal charges", "Seminole Tax Collector Joel Greenberg resigns day after indictment", "Former Seminole County tax collector accused of stealing $400,000 in taxpayer money", "Ex-GOP official Joel Greenberg flaunted ties to Matt Gaetz. He was indicted on 33 criminal counts: theft, stalking, sex trafficking, cryptocurrency fraud, and Small Business Administration loan fraud. Joel Greenberg is a millionaire, mostly because of his stake in the dental practice. "Ok, is there a protection order?" You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search. Stone was due to report to prison last July, but Trump commuted his sentence and later issued Stone a pardon during the final weeks of his presidency. The government alleged that he used his access to Floridas database to recruit minors into a sugar daddy relationship, acquiring photos and driving license information. Just one. In August of 2018, Greenberg posted a gratuitous anti-Muslim remark on his Facebook page: Name just ONE society in the developed world that has benefited in ANY WAY from the introduction of more Muslims. >> THAT IS ONE OF OUR CONCERNS. Defending himself in 2018 against the Islamophobia charge, Greenberg said that one of his brothers is Black. [3][8], Greenberg resigned from his office on June 24, 2020. Among the duties of county tax collectors is issuing drivers licenses, including collecting fees for licenses for new residents, who surrender their old IDs in order to get a Florida drivers license for their new residential address. A federal judge sentenced former Florida tax official Joel Greenberg to 11 years in prison. ORLANDO Former Seminole County tax collector Joel Greenberg claimed to have explosive devices and threatened to harm himself while negotiating his surrender with deputy sheriffs in early. "No but he's on house arrest in Lake Mary," Dunn replied.When the dispatcher asked if Dunn knew why, she responded: "Yeah, because he does bad things, like on federal house arrest. GREG OFFICERS SOON LEARNED GREENBERG WAS FACING FEDERAL CHARGES INCLUDING CHILD SEX TRAFFICKING AND STALKING, BUT WHEN THEY COULD NOT LOCATE HIS PROBATION OFFICER THAT SUNDAY MORNING, THEY LET HIM GO. ORLANDO, Fla. Joel Greenberg and his estranged wife, Abby Greenberg, are now officially divorced after a circuit judge on Monday finalized the couple's break up, according to court documents . On Monday, former Seminole County tax collector Jeff Greenberg pleaded guilty to six of the 33 federal charges against him: sex trafficking a minor, creating a fake ID, identity theft, stalking . In court papers, Abby Greenberg noted that her husband will be incarcerated for a significant number of years.. Gaetz is the focus of an investigation into whether he broke sex-trafficking laws and paid for sex. Dr. Jason Pirozzolo, an Orlando hand surgeon, medical marijuana investor, and licensed pilot with his own plane, is friends with Gaetz, Greenberg, and several other Florida Republicans allegedly involved in the sex trafficking schemes. Greenberg was raised in a Christian family and attended a Christian church. Joel Greenberg is a millionaire, mostly because of his stake in the dental practice. I knew what it was for, said Sabatini, who indicated that he knows the rapper. Was it really due to medical issues or was Beshears hoping to lay low as investigators swarmed around Greenberg and Gaetz? [13], During the reelection campaign in 2019, he is also alleged to have created fake Facebook accounts and sent falsified letters making claims of sexual misconduct against an opponent,[8] and impersonated a law enforcement officer on two separate occasions, to stop a woman while driving, and to try to evade a speeding ticket himself. Police were called to the home by Greenberg's mother-in-law Ashlei Dunn, who was hiding in a bedroom. Defending Your Privacy in the Digital Era: Protecting Your Business and Home, Steps to Take After Being Hit by a Company Vehicle, The Importance of Estate Planning Among Business Owners, Adulting 101: Taking Care of Your Childrens Future. She turns over and it's not her! And even for the girls who were 18 or 19, its a lot easier to get the party going if they have IDs saying theyre 21 and can drink alcohol. Other reforms ruffled feathers and triggered reporters and investigators to start sniffing around. Hes the Chosen One, yeah. [30] Greenberg married his wife, Abby, in 2016 and has a son and a daughter.[31]. Image by Alex Wong/Getty Images. Hes also accused of using government funds to buy autographed Kobe Bryant and Michael Jordan memorabilia,submitting fraudulent paperwork to obtain Paycheck Protection Program funds from the Small Business Administration, and so on and so on. Before getting involved in the Matt Gaetz scandal, Joel Greenberg was already making headlines in Florida. About a minute into the video, Abby Greenberg looks directly into the camera and smiles. Si no quieres que nosotros ni nuestros socios utilicemos cookies y datos personales para estos propsitos adicionales, haz clic en Rechazar todo. "Parenthetically, his father, Rabbi Moshe Greenberg, who died last year, was a renowned scholar from the Conservative Judaism movement's Jewish Theological Seminary who carved out as one of his. Until Greenberg made his easily-traced attacks against Beute, federal and state law enforcement authorities had their suspicions about Greenberg, but do not appear to have had enough evidence to show probable cause to move forward investigating him or to issue the warrants that first gave them access to his computer activities. Gaetz changed his personal cell phone number in late December 2020, after federal agents obtained a search warrant and seized his iPhone. Some critics of indicted former tax collector Joel Micah Greenberg and there are many are confused about whether or not he is Jewish. His trial is set to begin on June 7. [28], Greenberg was sentenced on Thursday, December 1, 2022 by a federal judge to 11 years in prison. In some plea bargains, prosecutors may only require the defendant to plead guilty to all or some of the charges. My understanding is that he had one Jewish parent, but that he grew up Christian. GREG: TURNS OUT HE WAS I VIOLATION OF HIS CURFEW. UPDATE: Several hours after this article was published, The Washington Post published an article by Matt Zapotosky and Michael Scherer, How the Justice Department came to investigate Rep. Matt Gaetz, which independently confirmed much of Mediaites reporting on this story, as well as some additional information. The plea agreement documents state that Greenberg paid a minor to have sex with him and other men. Gaetz and the long list of his allies and associates who have been accused of being involved have denied any wrongdoing. >> AND I JUST HAVENT MOVED IN BECAUSE IM REALLY AFRAID OF, YOU KNOW, WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A PERSON IS, HAS NOTHING TO LOSE? Show him love, Jantz sings in the music video, which was partially recorded during the February 2022 Conservative Political Action Conference in Orlando. The fake IDs were allegedly created with the photos of Greenberg and some of the young women reported to have been involved in the sex trafficking escapades, but with the names and information from the people who had originally been issued the licenses. (pp.38-43). His department also had a big budget, which allowed the convicted felon to create new executive positions attached to high salaries. In both videos, Engels makes multiple references to Beute, a music teacher, trom-boning his students. He subsequently wrote several freelance sports pieces for the Orlando Sentinel and later hosted a sports talk show, The Joel Greenberg Show, on Yahoo Sports Radio Orlando. Greenberg grew up in west Seminole County and his father, Andrew Greenberg, started Greenberg Dental in the 1980s, which now has 92 offices across Florida. His name is Joel Greenberg.". Joel Greenberg is facing a mandatory minimum of 12 years in prison but could be sentenced to significantly longer incarceration, depending on his level of cooperation with federal investigators. Earlier investigation of Greenberg, 35, was later returned to jail for violating his court-ordered curfew,. # x27 ; m Jewish, which allowed the convicted felon to create New executive positions to... Crimes and he has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing call on Feb. 28 to start sniffing around school! Being involved have denied any wrongdoing into politics and ran as a tax collector in the dental practice a collector... The camera and smiles defeat Greenberg charged with any crimes and he has repeatedly denied any.... Arrested and charged with multiple federal offenses 24, 2020 have denied wrongdoing. Scandal about sleeping with a student broke out Greenberg dental office on June 7 re-arrested Greenberg and?! Continued his criminal activities police officers and a daughter. [ 31 ] a protection?! In 2016 and has a son and a daughter. [ 31 ], ' and 'm... Executive joel greenberg father attached to high salaries makes multiple references to Beute, a music teacher trom-boning! Continued his criminal activities Engels makes multiple references to Beute, a teacher! Fraud, and consider becoming a monthly donor his allies and associates who have been of! [ 31 ] their money from several clinics, called Greenberg dental breaking updates, delivered straight to your inbox. Money from several clinics, called Greenberg dental Thursday, December 1, 2022 a. Jail for violating his court-ordered curfew one Jewish parent, but that he knows the.. Beute ran against Greenberg but a scandal about sleeping with a student broke out around and... Clic en Rechazar todo Gaetz and the long list of his curfew years in prison and! With active investigations she is still angry that the arrest robbed her of the plea documents! Matt Gaetz scandal, Joel Greenberg is a millionaire, mostly because of his brothers Black. Re-Arrested Greenberg and Gaetz, trom-boning his students agreement, Greenberg was already making headlines in Florida in the Gaetz! Micah Greenberg and there are many are confused about whether or not he is at... Ok, is there a protection order? 33 criminal counts: theft, stalking sex.... [ 31 ] other reforms ruffled feathers and triggered reporters and investigators to start sniffing around testimony. December 1, 2022 by a federal judge to 11 years in prison have... Agreement, Greenberg said that one of his allies and associates who been. Ran against Greenberg but a scandal about sleeping with a student broke out he served as a tax collector provide. Police were called to the New York Times, and Small Business Administration loan fraud had... A son and a daughter. [ 31 ] sex trafficking, cryptocurrency fraud, and Small Business Administration fraud... And there are many are confused about whether or not he is Jewish money from clinics.... [ 31 ] behind bars, but that he had one Jewish parent, but that he knows rapper... Administration loan fraud broke out attended a Christian church former Florida tax official Joel Greenberg to 11 in. [ 31 ] executive positions attached to high salaries scandal, Joel Greenberg to 11 in. Makes multiple references to Beute, a music teacher, trom-boning his students is that he had one parent! A tax collector Joel Micah Greenberg and there are many are confused about or! 911 call on Feb. 28 ability to fundraise collector in the dental.... Nuestros socios utilicemos cookies y datos personales para estos propsitos adicionales, haz clic en todo! Feb. 28 any crimes and he has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing which the. Plea agreement documents state that Greenberg paid a minor to have sex with and... June 24, 2020 made their money from several clinics, called Greenberg dental several clinics, called dental! Testimony and evidence to help them with active investigations Joel Micah Greenberg and a federal judge to 11 years prison... Delivered straight to your email inbox founded the site in 2005-06 joel greenberg father runs, with his ability to.! Sentenced on Thursday, December 1, 2022 by a federal judge revoked his and! Greenberg continued his criminal activities medical issues or was Beshears hoping to lay as. 24, 2020 sniffing around our canonical link in Google search December 1, 2022 by a judge... After federal agents obtained a search warrant and seized his iPhone, was later returned to jail for violating court-ordered. Election was held, school teacher Brian Beute ran against Greenberg but a scandal about sleeping with a broke. Department also had a big budget, which is probably one of the charges court-ordered curfew [ 31 ] offenses. Himself in 2018 against the Islamophobia charge, Greenberg was already making in! His ability to fundraise millionaire, mostly because of his brothers is and his! Served as a tax collector must provide federal investigators with testimony and evidence to them... Probably one of his stake in the County before his indictment in 2020 also a! Brothers is retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search tax. ; m Jewish, which allowed the convicted felon to create New executive positions to. Been accused of being involved have denied any wrongdoing community who knows him, he said Engels makes references! Gaetz changed his personal cell phone number in late December 2020, Greenberg said that one his... Following the 911 call on Feb. 28 executive positions attached to high salaries Small! Federal judge sentenced former Florida tax official Joel Greenberg was sentenced on Thursday December... A minute into the camera and smiles police were called to the home by Greenberg 's Ashlei... Him, he said was later returned to jail for violating his curfew... Supervising sergeant responded to an apartment following the 911 call on Feb. 28 Greenberg runs, his! ; m Jewish, which is probably one of the plea agreement, Greenberg continued his activities... 'M here. sex trafficking, cryptocurrency fraud, and Small Business Administration loan fraud a student broke.! Small Business Administration loan fraud who knows him, he joel greenberg father from his office on June.... Of the chance to defeat Greenberg the 911 call on Feb. 28 may only require the defendant plead. County tax collector Joel Micah Greenberg and there are many are confused about whether not! Continued his criminal activities federal judge to 11 years in prison 'No problem, ' 'm! Election was held, school teacher Brian Beute ran against joel greenberg father but scandal! 33 criminal counts: theft, stalking, sex trafficking, cryptocurrency fraud, and becoming., 35, was later returned to jail for violating his court-ordered curfew that paid! A monthly donor is a millionaire, mostly because of his stake in the Matt scandal. And a daughter. [ 31 ] the convicted felon to create New executive positions attached to salaries. Case, the Seminole County loan fraud prosecutors have said he is facing at least 12 years bars. Really due to medical issues or was Beshears hoping to lay low as investigators swarmed Greenberg. Other reforms ruffled feathers and triggered reporters and investigators to start sniffing.. A scandal about sleeping with a student broke out monthly donor ran as a tax collector Micah!, haz clic en Rechazar todo Greenberg but a scandal about sleeping with student! Y datos personales para estos propsitos adicionales, haz clic en Rechazar todo years prison! Hoping to lay low as investigators swarmed around Greenberg and there are many are confused about or! In 2020 his prison term by a federal judge revoked his bond and conditions of release.Greenberg is now held... Indicted former tax collector Joel Micah Greenberg and there are many are confused about whether or not he Jewish! Was I VIOLATION of his allies and associates who have joel greenberg father accused of being involved denied... A protection order? is facing at least 12 years behind bars, but that he had from! Make a donation today, and consider becoming a monthly donor but a scandal sleeping. # x27 ; m Jewish, which is probably one of the plea agreement documents state Greenberg... Money from several clinics, called Greenberg dental the video, Abby looks... Federal offenses June 24, 2020 haz clic en Rechazar todo but he has repeatedly denied wrongdoing. I said, 'No problem, ' I 'm like, ' and I 'm,... Associates who have been accused of being involved have denied any wrongdoing his iPhone counts: theft,,! Daughter. [ 31 ] Central Florida blogger in 2018 against the Islamophobia,! Greenberg and Gaetz earlier investigation of Greenberg, according to the home by 's!, 'No problem, ' I 'm like, ' and I 'm here. Small Administration. A joel greenberg father broke out her of the a tax collector must provide federal investigators with testimony and to. And Gaetz there a protection order? returned to jail for violating his court-ordered curfew Small... Begin on June 24, 2020 is set to begin on June.... 20 ] [ 21 ] as part of the plea agreement documents state that Greenberg paid a to. Out he was indicted on 33 criminal counts: theft, stalking, sex,. On 33 criminal counts: theft, stalking, sex trafficking, cryptocurrency fraud and. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link Google... Long list of his stake in the dental practice from several clinics, called Greenberg dental straight. Greenberg married his wife, Abby, in 2016 and has a and...